[SIGCIS-Members] Bitter dispute over Bletchley Park's future

[Brian Randell]

Hi :

The subject line is the BBC's headline for a news report broadcast last Friday, but no longer available on the BBC website.

>From ZDNet:
 http://www.zdnet.com/national-computer-museum-downgraded-by-bletchley-park-7000025636/

>       National computer museum downgraded by Bletchley Park
> 
> Summary: Bletchley Park has secured £8 million of Lottery funding as the home of Britain's wartime codebreaking, but has now shortened its guided tours by excluding the National Museum of Computing's Colossus and Tunny Galleries, which are at the heart of that codebreaking success. It's like staging Hamlet without the prince.
> 
> The National Museum of Computing (TNMOC) at Bletchley Park is being isolated by the new management regime at Bletchley Park Trust, which has started an £8 million Lottery-funded restoration project. At least one of its long-serving volunteers has been dismissed for including TNMOC in a guided tour, and some established attractions are being evicted. This includes a selection of Churchill memorabilia and a model railway that was popular with children.
> 
> The problems were exposed by tearful scenes in a BBC TV news broadcast on Friday (Bletchley Park's bitter dispute over its future, above), followed up by a TNMOC statement today (Monday).
> 
> The Trust has reduced its guided tour of Bletchley Park from 90 minutes or more to 60 minutes, but saved time by excluding all of the computer museum, including the Colossus and Tunny Galleries. Showing visitors these galleries got Tony Carroll fired.
> 
> "They haven’t got a clue," Carroll told the BBC. "They are ruining this place."
> 
> On its website, the Trust says the BBC News report "created an impression of disharmony" and claims "this is not an accurate impression". However, disharmony clearly exists, because TNMOC says it is "very much opposed to the fragmentation of Bletchley Park currently being undertaken by the Bletchley Park Trust". This goes beyond its exclusion from guided tours to the erection of "gates and barriers between its own display area and Block H [which] will almost certainly prove divisive."
> 
> The Trust's statement says: "The National Museum of Computing was formed in 2006 and is run by a separate charitable trust. It willingly entered into a lease agreement with the Bletchley Park Trust to rent Block H on the Bletchley Park site to house its museum. This museum remains on-site and accessible, by way of a separate admission charge, to anyone visiting Bletchley Park." Although this is strictly true, it's also a very divisive line to take.
> 
> The fact is that Bletchley Park is a pleasant little mansion that nobody would have heard of -- or bothered to rescue -- had it not been the temporary home of Britain's World War II codebreakers, and had those codebreakers not broken Germany's cyphers. That they did it with some of the first electronic computers made Bletchley Park not just of national but of international importance.
> 
> A visit to Bletchley Park that doesn't include the Colossus rebuild is like a Hamlet without the prince.
> 
> The campaign to save Bletchley Park depended almost wholly on the code-creaking aspect, and it was the Colossus rebuild and similar efforts by TNMOC that generated public interest and, ultimately, financial support for the whole site. Having trousered the Lottery money, it now looks as though the Trust wants to keep it. In TNMOC's words: "Negotiations with the Bletchley Park Trust to achieve a fair and equitable financial arrangement to give all Bletchley Park fee-paying visitors access to Colossus and Tunny have proved exceedingly difficult.
<snip>

YouTube version of the BBC News item (no longer available via the BBC News website):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V-cXx5PYRiw

The National Museum of Computing's statement:

http://www.tnmoc.org/news/news-releases/deciphering-discontent-statement-tnmoc-trustees

The Bletchley Park Trust's response:

http://www.bletchleypark.org.uk/news/v.rhtm/Progress_in_Perspective-755840.html


This is all very sad. My own sympathies are entirely with The National Museum of Computing.

Cheers

Brian

--
School of Computing Science, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne,
NE1 7RU, UK
EMAIL = Brian.Randell at ncl.ac.uk   PHONE = +44 191 222 7923
FAX = +44 191 222 8232  URL = http://www.cs.ncl.ac.uk/people/brian.randell